Episode 3 - French PCB Manufacturing Versus Asia: Marc Simonneau (ICAPE)
Video hosted by YouTube: playing it here means accepting YouTube's cookies.
I welcome Marc Simonneau, a printed circuit board expert at ICAPE, to tackle a tough question: can French and European PCB manufacturing still compete with Asia?
Marc looks back on the closure of most PCB factories in France: lack of vision and investment, international competition, geopolitical tensions. He also explains what it would take to stop the bleeding in Europe and attract young people to these careers.
The episode is also very practical for designers: choosing between lead-free HAL and ENIG finishes (cost and lead time), panelization, checking Gerber data on receipt, common mistakes in files, and why a complete, standardized specification sheet matters. Finally, Marc discusses complex boards such as rigid-flex and how to limit the risk of copying.
Episode chapters
Click a timestamp to play the video from that point.
- 0:00 Introduction and announcement
- 2:57 Start of the interview: thanks and context
- 8:45 Marc's career in the PCB industry
- 10:07 Why the PCB is so critical
- 11:58 The shrinking number of PCB factories in France
- 12:40 Introducing ICAPE and its philosophy
- 14:52 The challenges of staying exclusively French
- 21:10 Question from Christian Maudet: what was missing to keep PCB manufacturing in France?
- 21:32 Lack of vision and international competition
- 24:22 Competitiveness and productivity
- 27:59 The impact of geopolitical tensions on the PCB industry
- 32:59 ICAPE's commitment to French industry
- 34:49 Why accurate input data matters for manufacturing
- 37:39 The risk of copying and ICAPE's role as a filter
- 38:22 Common issues in technical specifications
- 38:44 Surface finishes: lead-free HAL and ENIG
- 42:20 Cost and lead time by finish
- 42:50 ICAPE's advisory role
- 47:23 How technologies and materials have evolved
- 52:57 Underinvestment in the PCB industry
- 56:08 Comparison with other struggling industries
- 58:10 A rant about politicized budgets
- 59:29 ICAPE's services beyond PCB distribution
- 1:00:41 Panelization and pick-and-place machine constraints
- 1:01:41 Downtime and waste reduction
- 1:06:31 The PCB designer's role and design verification
- 1:07:46 Quality control of Gerber data on receipt
- 1:11:23 Common issues in Gerber data
- 1:12:29 Why the specification sheet is critical
- 1:14:55 Standardizing specification sheets
- 1:17:24 The preferred specification sheet format
- 1:18:26 Essential information in a specification sheet
- 1:20:36 A call to collaborate on standardization
- 1:21:19 Passing on the knowledge of experienced professionals
- 1:23:09 Stopping the bleeding in the European PCB industry
- 1:23:58 Attracting young people to PCB careers
- 1:24:33 Marc's journey and passion for PCBs
- 1:30:08 The precision of PCB manufacturing, compared to pastry-making
- 1:31:07 Respecting processes and irreducible lead times
- 1:32:21 Manufacturing variability even when processes are followed
- 1:37:01 The challenges of complex boards (rigid-flex)
- 1:44:33 ICAPE's role in quality control
- 1:46:37 The benefits of local sourcing and full EMS services
- 1:47:51 The risk of losing control of assembly without a strong local PCB industry
- 1:48:10 Sharing only PCB information to avoid copying
- 1:51:08 The passion for creating PCBs
- 1:52:26 A call to French PCB manufacturers
- 1:52:57 A final call for unity
- 1:53:16 Conclusion and thanks
Paid partnership: thank you to ICAPE for supporting the Dans les coulisses du PCB podcast.
Episode 1 - Christian Maudet (Thales): Standardizing Printed…
Episode 2 - Designing a Cellular and Satellite GPS Tracker: …
Episode 3 - French PCB Manufacturing Versus Asia: Marc Simon…
Episode 4 1/3 - Inside the Eiffage Factory: From Order to Co…
Episode 4 2/3 - How an SMT Line Works, from Solder Paste to …
Episode 4 3/3 - Reflow, Wave Soldering, Testing and Conforma…
Episode 5 1/2 - The Challenges of an EMS Provider: Mistakes,…
Episode 5 2/2 - Design for Assembly: BGAs, Via-in-Pad, Surfa…
Episode 6 1/2 - Millomaker: The Hidden Work Behind the Elect…
Episode 6 2/2 - Millomaker Answers Your Questions
Episode 7 - Can French Electronics Be Saved? Sébastien Rospi…
Episode 8 - Why Learning Electronics Has Become Essential